Fixing 7 Smith and Wesson Shield Problems Made Simple

My research with the Smith and Wesson Shield has been a mix of excitement and challenge.

Despite its solid reputation, users have faced problems in the field, from trigger pull issues to magazine-feeding concerns. In navigating these challenges, I’ve found opportunities for improvement.

Through personal experimentation and community insights, strategies have emerged to address reliability and performance issues.

By adopting a proactive approach, enthusiasts can enhance their Smith and Wesson Shield experience and ensure its reliability in any situation.

Let’s Explore!

Issues and Fixes at a Glance

7 ProblemsTheir Quick Solution
Extraction IssueInspect extractor arm, maintain clean casing, contact support.
Thumb Safety ProblemContact for switch to safety-less version.
Problem with the Magazine SpringContact Smith & Wesson for a replacement spring.
Feeding ProblemClean gun, replace magazine spring if problem persists.
Magazine ProblemAllowing filled magazines sit to ease loading frustrations.
Trigger IssueClean trigger assembly; consider aftermarket trigger kits.
Slide Lock IssueRound off square edge of slide lock controller.
Smith and Wesson Shield Problems
Smith and Wesson Shield Problems

Smith and Wesson Shield Problems With Their Practical Solution:

1. Extraction Issue:

A problem I’ve seen is when the gun doesn’t kick out the empty shell after shooting it. Imagine you’re at the range, firing away, and suddenly, the spent shell just won’t come out of the gun. Frustrating, right?

It’s a surprise that no shooter wants to happen, yet for various reasons, it can rear its head at the most inconvenient times.

When shooting, the main goal is to hit the target. But problems pulling out the bullet make the experience much worse.


Examine the extractor arm for wear or damage to tackle the extraction issue. Keeping the casing clean can also prevent jams caused by dirt buildup.

If the extractor is worn or broken, contact Smith & Wesson customer service for assistance. Regular cleaning of the extractor arm significantly improves its reliability.

When issues persisted, contacting customer service ensured prompt resolution. Smith & Wesson’s commitment to customer support will likely make a positive difference, even in Smith and Wesson 39-2 Problems cases.

2. Thumb Safety Problem:

In my research with the Smith & Wesson Shield 9mm, the thumb safety has a big problem. It’s easy to accidentally turn on the safety, making it hard to trust the gun when you need it most.

If the safety works right, you can handle how well the gun will perform in a critical moment.

This shows why it’s super important for guns to be reliable. Any uncertainty could be really bad, especially in fast-paced situations.


The good news for Smith & Wesson Shield owners is that the company has listened to feedback regarding the thumb safety issue.

A simple call or online guide can assist in switching to a safety-less version, making the transition smooth and bringing relief to users.

Discovering this solution was a game-changer for me. Navigating the thumb safety problem personally, transitioning to a safety-less version alleviated concerns, showing Smith & Wesson’s commitment to enhancing user experience.

3. Problem with the Magazine Spring:

Another common challenge is the magazine’s spring issue, where loading rounds feels like a frustrating tug-of-war. It’s akin to digging into the core problem, facing coil binding within the spring.

The root of this issue is the pressure exerted on the spring during loading and feeding, which leads to feeding problems and potential total jams.

Understanding these intricacies is vital for resolving feeding challenges and ensuring smooth firearm operation.


The fix was clear: contact Smith & Wesson. A simple call led to the course of action: a replacement spring.

Once the new spring was in hand, I switched it out with the old one.

Almost instantly, the problem was gone. The new magazine operated smoothly and was more reliable. Owners no longer experienced feeding issues, and they didn’t have to waste time troubleshooting. Replacing the spring was the solution.

4. Feeding Problem:

To meet a feeding problem was more than just an issue; it disrupted firearm operations.

The magazine failed to properly set the last few rounds, causing them to get stuck at awkward angles.

This problem escalated during shooting sessions, with the slide often failing to pick up the next bullet, posing reliability issues, especially in high-stakes situations.

Upon inspection, dirty or incompatible ammunition exacerbated the problem.


The good news for those grappling with the feeding problem is that there’s an easy fix. Often, the issue stems from a dirty magazine or a spring problem.

  • A thorough cleaning of the gun and magazine can resolve this issue.
  •  If the feeding problem persists despite cleaning, consider swapping out the magazine’s spring.

This simple step fixed the problem for many users earlier. It’s a small bet that often does the trick, ensuring your firearm’s smooth and reliable operation.

5. Magazine Problem:

Whether loading the magazines or getting rounds to sit properly, it can feel like a mini workout. While some brush it off as no big deal, it’s tough, especially during range sessions.

A special tool is sometimes needed to insert a fully loaded magazine into the gun. The magazine can resist even with a new spring, making loading unnecessarily difficult.

This wrinkle can be frustrating, impacting the overall firearm experience.


Fixing issues during loading and unloading can be frustrating, especially when you’re eager to hit the range.

One solution is to give the bullets and spring a chance to relax.

Fill the magazines and let them sit for a week. Often, the springs will have loosened up, making them easier to handle without battling with a rigid mechanism. This practical approach can ease your loading struggles.

6. Trigger Issue:

No, let’s talk about another issue. One big issue people notice is problems with the trigger.

Whether you’re in the heat of competition or relying on your firearm for personal protection, the last thing you want is a malfunctioning trigger.

The trigger must respond smoothly during field tests, ensuring a precise and reliable pull.

However, some users report experiencing an uneven or gritty feel, which undermines each shot’s consistent and predictable nature.


One surprising yet highly effective method is thoroughly cleaning the trigger assembly.

Additionally, consider investing in after-market trigger kits.

Many users have reported a significant difference in the feel and performance of their firearms after installing these kits.

After trying various kits, many firearm enthusiasts have described the difference as night and day. The trigger pull becomes more manageable, allowing for greater control and accuracy when handling the gun.

Therefore, it’s crucial to consider these solutions, as they can greatly improve your overall shooting experience.

If you’re experiencing any Smith and Wesson 22A Problems, addressing them promptly will ensure smooth operation and enhance your shooting sessions.

7. Slide Lock Issue:

The slide lock issue is particularly infamous when delving into the Smith and Wesson shield problems. Many users have encountered this hiccup during field tests, where the slide fails to lock back after the last round.

It’s not something to brush off lightly; this quick action can be critical in high-stakes situations.

However, the Shield’s user-friendly design can become less so when the slide becomes stiff, refusing to lock back even when the magazine is empty.

Dealing with this stubborn resistance requires Herculean strength to release the slide.


To solve the slide lock issue, a straightforward fix can yield significant improvements.

Using 600-grit sandpaper, round off the square edge of the controller piece to address the problem effectively.

This simple adjustment results in a noticeably smoother operation of the slide lock, eliminating the feeling of pushing a boulder uphill during firearm use.

Though it may require some time and effort, this tweak ensures a smoother shooting experience in the long run.

Read more: Smith and Wesson Model 41 Problems.

My Final Conclusion:

The Smith & Wesson Shield has long been a popular choice among gun enthusiasts, but it has its issues like any firearm.

Some users may encounter challenges ranging from occasional extraction failures to inconsistent trigger pulls. However, it’s essential to recognize that these problems are fixable with some fine-tuning and attention to detail.

Despite the bumps in the road, the Shield still holds its own in a market saturated with options.

By contacting customer service or employing simple remedies like sandpaper and thorough cleaning, users can turn things around and enjoy a smoother shooting experience.

While these challenges may serve as deterrents, they can also be viewed as stepping stones toward mastering the firearm and achieving optimal performance.

My Friends Feedback:

My friends have shared their experiences with various striker-fired guns, like the M&P striker gun series.

They emphasize the importance of practicing using snap caps to prevent wear from dry firing. While they appreciate the operational mastery of these firearms, they also highlight the need to address flinching issues and ensure a proper grip for sub-second draw times.

Some have experimented with factory-ported models like the M&P Shield, which enhance accuracy and enable a rapid string of fire.

However, they caution against relying solely on compensated full-size guns and recommend micro 9mm options like the Sig P365 or Springfield Hellcat for concealment.

Amidst the rumors and videos circulating online about the Shield Plus, concerns have emerged regarding uncommanded discharges akin to issues with the Sig P320s.

While some critics dismiss these as denial from Sig fanboys, others attribute it to defective parts or manufacturing deficiencies.

Despite the occasional quality control hiccup, many still vouch for S&W’s commitment to customer service and the overall quality of their products.

The Shield Plus 9 3.1 remains a fairly priced option in its category.

Common Questions Asked About Smith and Wesson Shield Problems:

What is the safety problem with the Smith and Wesson shield?

Smith & Wesson has pinpointed two instances of M&P Shield EZ Pistols where the hammers supplied by our manufacturer exhibited cracks. In these particular firearms, the compromised hammers failed to properly engage the sear mechanism, leading to unintended round firing, slide cycling, and the potential for multiple discharges without trigger depression.

Will M&P Shield fire if dropped?

Smith & Wesson has detected an issue where the trigger bar pin could harm the lower trigger on specific models of the M&P Shield. This damage could compromise the firearm’s drop safety feature, potentially resulting in accidental discharge if the pistol is dropped.

What does M&P Shield stand for?

Smith & Wesson utilizes the “M&P” designation, which stands for “Military and Police.” This designation was first employed as a model identifier for their initialĀ double-action firearm.

Can I dry-fire my M&P Shield?

Dry firing an M&P is perfectly fine, especially for occasional use without a snap cap. However, if you plan to dry-fire frequently, you should use a snap cap for protection.

Is there a difference between M&P and M&P Shield?

They have very different textures. The original Smith and Wesson Shield is smooth and lacks texture, while the Smith and Wesson M&P 2.0 Shield has a notably aggressive texture, matching the grip of the Smith and Wesson M&P 2.0 Compact.

I worked hard on this post to help the shooters community. Spread the love

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *